Appeal Management
Appeal Management Procedure
Fair & Impartial Appeal Handling Process
ICV follows a structured and documented procedure for handling appeals lodged by clients against audit conclusions and decisions. Our appeal management process ensures impartial investigation, transparent communication, and timely resolution — with oversight from the CEO, Technical Committee, and Impartiality Committee at every stage.
5.1 Definition
Written complaints raised by our clients regarding dissatisfaction with our assessment output are categorized as an Appeal. This procedure governs how such appeals are received, investigated, and resolved.
5.0 Procedure
Our appeal handling procedure covers every stage from receipt and CEO review through investigation, corrective action, appellant updates, and final closure — with complete records maintained throughout.
-
STEP-01
Receipt of Appeal
Since this relates to our core process, there is a separate provision on our website for lodging an appeal. An appeal can also be made in writing to our office. As soon as any appeal is received, acknowledgment is sent to the client within 3 working days, promising appropriate action within one month. Record of all appeals is maintained for at least 4 years.
- Ref: Record of Appeals
-
STEP-02
CEO Review
All appeals are reviewed by the CEO upon receipt.
-
STEP-03
Investigation of Appeal
The CEO looks into appeals and, as per the situation, takes one or more of the investigative actions outlined below — ensuring a fair and impartial review of the client's concerns.
-
STEP-04
Monitoring & Tracking
Being the ultimate authority, the CEO monitors and tracks action taken since receipt of the appeal till closure of the process. It is ensured that persons involved in the dispute are not involved in making decisions related to the appeal. The Impartiality Committee also monitors the appeal handling process. All cases of appeal and complaints are necessarily reviewed by the Impartiality Committee during its six-monthly review meeting.
- Ref: MOM of the Impartiality Committee
-
STEP-05
Correction & Corrective Action
Based upon additional information received after investigation from multiple sources, the Technical Committee takes appropriate decision and it is documented. The same is communicated to the client. Corrections and corrective actions are taken, if required. The CEO takes appropriate action as per the decision made by the Technical Committee and records are maintained.
-
STEP-06
Updating of Appellant
The appellant is kept updated with progress in the appeal handling process. All appeals are resolved or closed within 3 months of registration. The decision of the Technical Committee is final and further appeal is not entertained. A formal appeal closure report is sent to the appellant stating all the actions taken and the final decision of the appeal handling authority.
-
STEP-07
Records & Client File
The decision of the CEO is recorded in the client's file. Summary of activities subsequent to appeal is recorded in a register ICV/Appeal/F-01. The record is retained for at least 4 years.
- Ref: ICV/Appeal/F-01 | Client File
-
STEP-08
Impartiality Committee Review
In case the appellant is not satisfied with the decision of the Technical Committee or CEO, to remove any suspicion of bias, ICV allows the appellant to put forward his or her case before the Impartiality Committee. The CEO voluntarily forwards all resolved and unresolved cases of appeals to the Impartiality Committee for their review and necessary guidance or instructions. Record of such references is also maintained in hard copy. The decision of the Impartiality Committee is final.
- Ref: ISO 17021-1:2015
5.4 Investigation Actions
Upon reviewing an appeal, the CEO may take one or more of the following actions depending on the nature and complexity of the case.
-
i
Documentary Evidence
Documentary evidence is requested from the client in support of their claim.
-
ii
Re-Audit
Another auditor is deputed to conduct a re-audit of those aspects which caused dispute and appeal.
-
iii
Impartiality Committee
The Impartiality Committee is kept updated regarding the appeal and subsequent action taken.
Records & References
All appeal-related activities are documented and retained in accordance with ISO 17021-1:2015 requirements. The following records are maintained:
- ICV/Appeal/F-01 — Summary register of all appeal activities, retained for at least 4 years.
- Client File — CEO decision and all related documentation kept in the concerned client's file.
- MOM of the Impartiality Committee — Record of Impartiality Committee review meetings and decisions.
Reference: ISO 17021-1:2015 | Records: ICV/Appeal/F-01, Client File, Record of MOM of the Impartiality Committee
Hi there! Need help?
Chat with us on WhatsApp for ISO certification and training.
Chat on WhatsApp +91 9711146710